1. Home  » 
  2. Insurance

Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023

The Best Renters Insurance for December 2023, based on affordability, comprehensive coverage, and excellent customer service, includes options like Allstate Nationwide, State Farm, Country Financial, Westfield, Chubb and American Family.

by Kowsalya

Updated Dec 02, 2023

Article continues below advertisement
Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023

Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023

The best renters insurance companies are reputable insurance providers that offer comprehensive coverage and excellent customer service to protect tenants and their belongings. These companies specialize in offering insurance policies specifically tailored for renters, providing financial protection against potential risks such as theft, fire, vandalism, and liability claims.

These insurance companies typically offer a range of coverage options to suit different needs and budgets, allowing renters to select the level of protection that aligns with their requirements.

The best renters insurance companies have a strong track record of prompt and fair claims handling, ensuring that policyholders receive timely compensation in the event of a covered loss. Here is the list of Best Renters Insurance Companies,


Cost for $15,000 Coverage

Complaint Level


$106 a year

Very low


$126 a year

Very low

State Farm

$122 a year

Very low

Country Financial

$150 a year

Very low


$159 a year

Very low


$114 a year

Very low

American Family

$152 a year

Very low


Allstate is the top pick as the best overall renters insurance company. It offers competitive rates for various types of renters and stands out with its affordability for $15,000, $30,000, and $50,000 personal property coverage. With a nationwide presence, Allstate is a reliable choice for renters seeking comprehensive coverage.


Nationwide is an excellent option for renters with poor credit, offering cost-effective rates. Renters can save over $100 annually by choosing Nationwide over some pricier competitors. With a presence in 43 states and Washington, D.C., it's widely accessible.

State Farm

State Farm is known for its affordability, particularly for renters seeking $50,000 personal property coverage. It also offers competitive rates for lower coverage amounts, making it an ideal choice for budget-conscious renters. State Farm is available nationwide.

Country Financial

Country Financial excels in offering expanded coverage options, including protection against power surge damage and antique breakage. Renters can also opt for additional coverage for issues like sump pump failure and sewer or drain backup. While its availability is primarily in the Midwest and West, it provides valuable coverage for those regions.


Westfield stands out for its convenience, allowing renters to combine their auto and renters insurance policies into one, streamlining their insurance management. It also offers competitive rates, especially for $50,000 personal property coverage. While it mainly serves the Midwest, it's a strong choice for those seeking bundled insurance.


Chubb caters to renters in gated communities with discounts and provides a range of other discounts, such as long-time customer incentives and security system discounts. It maintains a very low complaint level, ensuring customer satisfaction.

American Family

American Family offers generational discounts, providing lower renters insurance rates to young adults who are children of American Family customers. It combines competitive rates with minimal complaints, making it a suitable choice for families and young renters.

Article continues below advertisement
Article continues below advertisement

What is Renters Insurance?

Renters insurance is a type of insurance designed to meet the specific needs of tenants. Renters insurance, tailored for tenants, safeguards personal belongings against risks like theft and fire, while also providing liability coverage and covering additional living expenses. Not legally mandatory, it remains a wise financial decision, with average premiums of around $14 a month for $15,000 coverage. To get renters insurance, assess your needs, obtain quotes, and choose a reputable provider offering comprehensive coverage and excellent customer service.

Article continues below advertisement
Article continues below advertisement

How to Find the Best Renters Insurance?

To secure the best renters insurance, begin by assessing your coverage requirements, obtaining quotes from various insurance providers, and evaluating their customer service and reviews to make an informed choice that aligns with your specific needs and preferences. Here are some key points to note, 

Understand What Renters Insurance Covers

  • Renters' insurance covers personal property like furniture, clothing, jewelry, and electronics. It does not protect the physical apartment, as that is covered by the landlord's insurance.
  • It often includes liability insurance, which pays for injuries and damage you accidentally cause to others. You can choose the amount of liability coverage and consider adding umbrella insurance for extra protection.

Determine How Much Renters Insurance You Need

  • Assess the value of your personal belongings and consider how much you have to lose. Choose the appropriate amount of personal belongings coverage, such as $15,000 or $50,000.
  • Evaluate how much liability coverage you need. A general guideline is to have enough to cover potential losses in a lawsuit.

Choose a Renters Insurance Deductible

  • Decide on the deductible amount, which is the portion deducted from the payment of a claim. Higher deductibles lead to lower premiums, so consider your budget and risk tolerance.

Ask About Discounts

  • Inquire about available discounts from each insurance company you're considering. Utilizing these discounts can help lower your renter's insurance costs.

Check into Optional Renters Insurance Coverage Types

  • If interested, explore optional coverage types like replacement cost coverage or scheduling personal property. Understand the associated costs and benefits.

Compare Renters Insurance Quotes

  • Request quotes from multiple renters insurance companies, ensuring you compare policies with the same coverage amounts. Consider starting with your car insurance company, as bundling policies may lead to discounts.

Make an Application to the Company of Your Choice

  • Once you've found a suitable policy and company, complete the renter's insurance application. Many insurance companies offer online application options for convenience.

Consider Other Coverage Options

  • Keep in mind that renters insurance does not cover flood and earthquake damage. If you require such protection, explore separate policies specifically designed for those risks.
Article continues below advertisement
Article continues below advertisement

What Does Renters Insurance Cover?

Renters insurance provides valuable protection for tenants, extending beyond safeguarding personal belongings to include liability coverage and assistance with additional living expenses. This comprehensive coverage ensures financial security in unexpected situations, making it essential for renters to understand what exactly renters insurance covers.

Personal Property Coverage

  • Choose a policy limit for personal property, which represents the maximum amount your insurance company will pay if your belongings are damaged or stolen.
  • Consider whether to opt for replacement cost coverage or actual cash value (ACV). Replacement cost coverage pays to replace items at today's prices, while ACV takes depreciation into account.
  • Be aware of any special limits or sub-limits for certain types of items, such as jewelry, that may require additional coverage through scheduling.

Liability Insurance

  • Understand that renters insurance includes liability protection, which covers you in case of lawsuits for injuries or property damage caused to others.
  • Determine the liability coverage amount you need, as a typical policy may provide $100,000, but higher amounts can be chosen for better protection.
  • Recognize that liability insurance also covers your legal defense costs in such situations.

Medical Payments to Others

  • Note that renters insurance typically includes medical payments coverage, which pays for smaller medical bills regardless of fault.
  • Understand that this coverage applies when someone sustains minor injuries on your premises, such as a guest slipping and falling.
  • Start with coverage amounts typically starting at $1,000 for medical payments to others.

Additional Living Expenses

  • Be aware of the coverage known as additional living expenses or loss of use.
  • Understand that if your rented property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event, this coverage can pay for hotel stays, meals, and other extra costs you incur.
  • Keep all relevant receipts and documentation for expenses incurred during the period of displacement in order to make a claim.

At MarketsHost, gain insights into why Insurance is your ultimate shield against life's uncertainties, ensuring peace of mind.

What’s Not Covered by Renters Insurance?

While renters insurance offers essential protection for personal belongings and liability, it's crucial to be aware of its limitations. Not everything falls under the coverage umbrella, and understanding what's not covered by renters insurance helps renters make informed decisions about additional policies and precautions to safeguard their assets. Some of them are,

  • The physical building you live in; is the landlord's responsibility.
  • Incidents in common areas (e.g., someone slipping in a hallway).
  • Belongings of roommates; each person needs their own policy.
  • Vehicle damage or theft; is covered by auto insurance.
  • Damage from insects or pets.
  • Floods; a separate policy is needed.
  • Earthquakes; additional earthquake insurance is required.
  • Mudslides; specific coverage is necessary.

How Much is Renters Insurance?

According to sources the average cost of renters insurance is $173 per year for a policy with $15,000 of personal property coverage. This translates to approximately $14 per month. For policies with higher coverage limits, such as $30,000 of personal property coverage, the average cost increases to $227 per year or around $19 per month.

It is noteworthy that doubling the personal property coverage from $15,000 to $30,000 typically results in only a small increase of approximately $5 per month. Renters insurance offers a cost-effective way to safeguard your belongings and obtain valuable liability coverage. Prices for renters insurance among different companies are generally comparable.


$15,000 Coverage

$30,000 Coverage

$50,000 Coverage









State Farm








Country Financial




American Family




























Best Renters Insurance Companies of December 2023 - FAQs

1. What criteria determine the best renters insurance companies of December 2023?

Reputable providers with comprehensive coverage and excellent customer service.

2. Which company is recommended as the best overall for renters insurance?

Allstate, offering competitive rates and nationwide coverage.

3. What distinguishes Nationwide as an excellent option for renters with poor credit?

Nationwide provides cost-effective rates, potentially saving over $100 annually.

4. Why is State Farm considered affordable, especially for renters seeking $50,000 personal property coverage?

State Farm offers competitive rates for various coverage amounts, making it budget-friendly.

5. What sets Chubb apart in catering to renters in gated communities?

Chubb provides discounts for gated community residents, along with various other discount options.

Disclaimer : The above information is for general informational purposes only. All information on the Site is provided in good faith, however we make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability or completeness of any information on the Site.