Best Homeowners Insurance of November 2023
The top homeowners insurance providers of November 2023, based on average annual costs and complaint levels, include American Family, Nationwide, USAA*, Westfield, Chubb, and more.
by Kowsalya
Updated Nov 06, 2023
On This Page
Best Homeowners Insurance of November 2023
Homeowners insurance serves as a crucial financial safeguard, providing assistance in case of damage or destruction to your home and belongings caused by covered incidents, like kitchen fires, wildfires, or storms.
Amid the soaring home insurance rates in numerous states this summer, we conducted a comprehensive assessment of average rates, complaint levels, and coverage offerings from major insurers across the country to identify the top home insurance companies. Here is a table with the companies, Forbes Advisor Rating, Complaint Level, and Average Annual Home Insurance Cost for $350,000 in Dwelling Coverage:
Company |
Average Annual Cost |
American Family |
$1,251 |
Nationwide |
$1,309 |
USAA* |
$1,243 |
Westfield |
$1,164 |
Chubb |
$1,717 |
Erie |
$1,378 |
State Farm |
$1,475 |
Farmers |
$1,877 |
Allstate |
$1,313 |
Auto-Owners |
$1,645 |
Progressive |
$746 |
Country Financial |
$2,283 |
Shelter |
$2,337 |
Travelers |
$2,404 |
1. American Family
American Family has a very low complaint level. The average annual home insurance cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with American Families is $1,251. To learn more about their offerings and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
2. Nationwide
With a very low complaint level, Nationwide is a reliable option for home insurance. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Nationwide is $1,309. To explore their coverage options further and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
3. USAA*
USAA boasts a very low complaint level, making it a popular choice for homeowners. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with USAA is $1,243. To find out more about their insurance solutions and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
4. Westfield
With, Westfield is known for its reliability in the insurance industry. They maintain a very low complaint level, indicating high customer satisfaction. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Westfield is $1,164. To explore their offerings and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
5. Chubb
Chubb holds a very low complaint level. While their average annual home insurance cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage is $1,717, their reputation for excellent service may be worth the investment. To learn more about their coverage options and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
6. Erie
Erie maintains a very low complaint level, making them a reliable choice for homeowners. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Erie is $1,378. To explore their insurance solutions and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
7. State Farm
With a very low complaint level, State Farm is a well-established insurance provider. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with State Farm is $1,475. To find out more about their offerings and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
8. Farmers
Farmers, with very low complaint level, is a reliable option for homeowners. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Farmers is $1,877. To explore their coverage options and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
9. Allstate
Allstate has maintained a very low complaint level. The average annual home insurance cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Allstate is $1,313. To learn more about their insurance solutions and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
10. Auto-Owners
With a very low complaint level, Auto-Owners is known for its reliability in the insurance industry. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with auto owners is $1,645. To explore their offerings and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
11. Progressive
Progressive has a low complaint level. Offering competitive rates, the average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Progressive is $746. To find out more about their coverage options and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
12. Country Financial
With a very low complaint level, Country Financial is a reliable option for home insurance. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Country Financial is $2,283. To learn more about their insurance solutions and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
13. Shelter
The shelter maintains a very low complaint level. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Shelter is $2,337. To explore their coverage options and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via EverQuote.
14. Travelers
With a very low complaint level, Travelers is an established insurance provider. The average annual cost for $350,000 in dwelling coverage with Travelers is $2,404. To find out more about their offerings and compare rates, you can visit their website or check with participating partners via Ever
What is Homeowners Insurance?
Homeowners insurance is a crucial financial safety net that offers comprehensive protection for homeowners. It encompasses not only the physical structure of the home but also personal possessions within it, ensuring that any losses or damages resulting from unforeseen events like fires, natural disasters, burglaries, or accidents on the property are covered.
Additionally, homeowners insurance includes liability coverage, which shields homeowners in the event they are sued for accidental injuries or property damage that occurs on their premises. This insurance is not only a practical necessity but also a vital means of safeguarding a homeowner's investment and providing peace of mind for the future.
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance Companies of 2023
By seeking out the most affordable home insurance, you have the potential to save a substantial amount, ranging from hundreds to even thousands of dollars. It is essential to assess your coverage requirements and obtain quotes from multiple homeowners insurance companies to identify the best rates.
Our analysis revealed significant variations in rates, with differences of over $2,000 per year between the least expensive and the most expensive home insurance options among the companies we evaluated. This emphasizes the importance of shopping around to secure the most cost-effective and suitable home insurance policy for your needs.
Home Insurance Company |
Average Annual Cost |
Percentage Difference from National Average of $1,935 |
Progressive |
$901 |
53% |
Westfield |
$1,244 |
36% |
USAA* |
$1,478 |
24% |
Allstate |
$1,526 |
21% |
American Family |
$1,590 |
18% |
Set sail with MarketsHost, where finance and business insights guide your journey to success.
What Are the Cheapest Home Insurance Companies by State?
Here is the table of the cheapest home insurance companies and their average monthly rates by state:
State |
Cheapest Home Insurance Company |
Average Monthly Rates |
Alabama |
Allstate |
$101 |
Alaska |
Allstate |
$69 |
Arizona |
American Family |
$75 |
Arkansas |
Shelter |
$160 |
California |
CSE |
$48 |
Colorado |
Auto-Owners |
$93 |
Connecticut |
Progressive |
$43 |
Delaware |
Cumberland |
$50 |
Florida |
Progressive |
$86 |
Georgia |
UPC Insurance |
$71 |
Hawaii |
Dongbu Insurance |
$17 |
Idaho |
Nationwide |
$48 |
Illinois |
Erie |
$73 |
Indiana |
Cincinnati Insurance |
$56 |
Iowa |
Nationwide |
$83 |
Kansas |
Auto-Owners |
$135 |
Kentucky |
Cincinnati Insurance |
$92 |
Louisiana |
State Farm |
$125 |
Maine |
Concord Group |
$37 |
Maryland |
Brethern Mutual |
$62 |
Massachusetts |
State Farm |
$41 |
Michigan |
Progressive |
$58 |
Minnesota |
Auto-Owners |
$87 |
Mississippi |
State Farm |
$180 |
Missouri |
Nationwide |
$88 |
Montana |
Kemper |
$73 |
Nebraska |
Nationwide |
$137 |
Nevada |
Universal North America |
$37 |
New Hampshire |
Amica |
$43 |
New Jersey |
UPC Insurance |
$34 |
New York |
Kemper |
$41 |
North Carolina |
State Farm |
$61 |
North Dakota |
State Auto |
$91 |
Ohio |
Ohio Mutual |
$49 |
Oklahoma |
Oklahoma Farmers Union |
$221 |
Oregon |
Mutual of Enumclaw |
$33 |
Pennsylvania |
Cumberland |
$39 |
Rhode Island |
State Farm |
$52 |
South Carolina |
Heritage Insurance |
$57 |
South Dakota |
Nationwide |
$92 |
Tennessee |
American National |
$61 |
Texas |
Nationwide |
$136 |
Utah |
Unigard |
$36 |
Vermont |
Vermont Mutual |
$38 |
Virginia |
Cincinnati Insurance |
$33 |
Washington |
Pemco |
$30 |
West Virginia |
Progressive |
$68 |
Wisconsin |
Rockford Mutual |
$49 |
Wyoming |
Nationwide |
$70 |
What Does Home Insurance Cover?
Home insurance, also known as homeowners insurance, offers a comprehensive range of coverage to protect your home, belongings, and financial well-being. Here are the key components of what home insurance typically covers:
Dwelling Coverage
- Description: This coverage safeguards the physical structure of your home, including walls, roof, floors, and built-in appliances.
- Purpose: It helps repair or rebuild your home if it is damaged or destroyed by covered perils, such as fires, storms, vandalism, or theft.
- Consideration: The coverage amount should reflect the cost of rebuilding your home, not its market value.
Personal Property Coverage
- Description: Personal property coverage protects your belongings, including furniture, clothing, electronics, and household items.
- Purpose: It assists in replacing or repairing personal items that are damaged, lost, or stolen due to covered events.
- Coverage Amount: Typically set between 50% to 70% of the dwelling coverage amount, but can be adjusted based on your needs.
Liability Insurance
- Description: Liability insurance covers injuries to others or property damage caused by your actions or negligence, both inside and outside your home.
- Purpose: It helps pay for medical bills, legal defense costs, and potential lawsuit judgments.
- Coverage Amount: It's advisable to have enough liability coverage to protect your assets in case of a lawsuit.
Additional Living Expenses (ALE) Coverage
- Description: Also known as "loss of use," ALE coverage covers extra expenses like temporary lodging, meals, and pet boarding if you can't live in your home during repairs due to a covered event.
- Purpose: It ensures you maintain a similar standard of living while your home is being restored.
- Coverage Amount: Typically a percentage of your dwelling coverage, but you can adjust it as needed
What Does Home Insurance Not Cover?
Home insurance, while comprehensive, does come with certain exclusions and limitations. Here's a detailed list of what home insurance typically does not cover:
- Ordinance or Law: Home insurance does not cover expenses related to government ordinances or laws that require the demolition, repair, or rebuilding of your home to meet local regulations or codes.
- Earth Movement: This category includes damages caused by earthquakes, landslides, and sinkholes. Specialized earthquake insurance may be needed for such events.
- Water Damage: Home insurance excludes damage from floods and water backup, such as sewage or drain overflow. Separate flood insurance is typically required for flood protection.
- Power Failure: If your home experiences damage due to a power failure, like spoiled food in your fridge, it is not covered under standard home insurance.
- Neglect: Neglecting to maintain your home, including failing to keep it adequately heated in cold weather, is not covered.
- War and Nuclear Hazard: Damages resulting from war, acts of war, and nuclear hazards are generally excluded.
- Intentional Loss: Any loss or damage intentionally caused by the homeowner or policyholder is not covered.
- Government Action: If the government seizes your property or takes any action related to your property, it is not covered.
- Wear and Tear: Normal wear and tear, gradual deterioration, and aging of your home and belongings are not insurable events.
- Environmental Factors: Damage caused by smog, dry rot, rust, or other forms of corrosion is typically excluded.
- Pollution: Home insurance does not cover damages related to the discharge, migration, seepage, escape, or release of pollutants.
- Smoke from Agricultural or Industrial Operations: Damage caused by smoke from farming or industrial activities may not be covered.
- Mechanical Breakdown: Home insurance does not cover mechanical breakdowns or latent defects that cause property damage.
- Structural Changes: Changes in the structure of your home due to factors like shrinking, settling, expansion, or bulging are typically excluded.
- Vermin and Pests: Damage caused by vermin, rodents, birds, or insects is not covered.
- Damage by Your Own Pets: If your pets cause damage to your property, it is generally excluded.
How to Save on Homeowners Insurance?
Saving on homeowners insurance is possible with these strategies:
- Shop Around: Obtain homeowners insurance quotes from multiple companies, ensuring they offer the same coverage levels for accurate comparisons.
- Maximize Discounts: Home insurance providers offer various discounts, including those for new or renovated homes, security systems, claims-free history, annual premium payments, multiple policies with the same company, and senior citizens.
- Consider Increasing Deductibles: A higher deductible can lower your premium. Ask your insurer about potential savings when increasing your deductible. For example, raising it from $250 to $1,000 can save you an average of $174 annually.
- Improve Your Credit: In most states, insurers use credit history to set rates. Improving your credit can lead to a higher credit-based insurance score, potentially lowering your homeowners insurance rates.
- Bundle Auto and Home Insurance: Combining home and auto insurance with the same company often results in discounts ranging from 5% to 25%. It simplifies policy management and can be cost-effective.
- Request Comparable Quotes: When bundling or seeking multiple policies from one insurer, ensure you request quotes for the same coverage levels with all applicable discounts considered.
- Limit Attractive Nuisances: Features like swimming pools, treehouses, or trampolines may increase your rates, as insurers consider them attractive nuisances. Limiting these can help lower your insurance costs.
Best Homeowners Insurance of November 2023-FAQs
1. What is homeowners insurance?
Homeowners insurance is a type of insurance policy that provides financial protection to homeowners in case their property, belongings, or liability are damaged or affected by covered perils, such as fire, theft, or natural disasters.
2. How do I find the best homeowners insurance?
To find the best homeowners insurance, you should compare quotes from multiple insurance companies, and consider coverage options, discounts, and customer reviews.
3. What does the best homeowners insurance typically cover?
The best homeowners insurance policies typically cover the dwelling (structure of the home), personal belongings, liability (injuries or property damage caused by the homeowner), additional living expenses (if the home is temporarily uninhabitable), and other specified perils.
4. What factors affect the cost of homeowners insurance?
The cost of homeowners insurance is influenced by various factors, including the location of the home, the dwelling coverage amount, the deductible chosen, the home's age and construction type, the homeowner's claims history, and the presence of safety features or security systems.
5. Are there any ways to save on homeowners insurance premiums?
Yes, there are several ways to save on homeowners insurance premiums.